Chilean harbour tug fleet: fuel per engine hour held steady for 18 months

Fitted harbour tugs held their fuel use per engine hour for 18 months after docking, while an unfitted tug in the same fleet rose 27%.

Orange harbour tug alongside, with a thick band of green weed and barnacles along the waterline

A Chilean harbour tug operator fitted GLOBAtech ultrasonic antifouling to its tugs at docking from July 2018. Over the next 18 months the first fitted tug’s fuel use per engine hour stayed within about 5% of its first quarter after docking, while an unfitted tug in the same fleet kept climbing: up 27% in the second half of 2019 against 2018, as the fitted tugs came down 3%.

Download the two-page case story (PDF)

The fleet

The operator runs harbour tugs and port launches in the Valparaíso Region. The tugs spend long hours alongside or at low speed in cold, productive water, and every tug that came in for fitting showed the same thing: weed and barnacles at the waterline, and heavy fouling on the hull and running gear by the time it reached the dock.

What was fitted

From July 2018, at docking: GLOBAtech’s H2oBioSonic system, the predecessor of ENVSonic. Control modules on board, transducers bonded to the inside of the hull, working alongside the existing antifouling paint. Seven tugs and the operator’s launches, ten vessels in all, were protected by November 2019, installed and supported by GLOBAtech’s Chilean partner. From 2020 the partner also trialled fitting before an underwater clean, so a vessel did not have to wait for its next docking.

What the data showed

The partner tracked fuel burned per main-engine hour from the operator’s records, tug by tug and quarter by quarter. Fouling builds from the day a tug leaves dock, so an unprotected hull burns a little more each quarter; a protected one should hold its line.

The first fitted tug held within 5% for 18 months while the unfitted tug kept climbing

Fuel burned per main-engine hour by quarter, indexed: each tug’s first quarter shown = 100

Index (first quarter = 100)

The first fitted tug held within 5% for 18 months while the unfitted tug kept climbingUnfitted tug: 100 to 188. First fitted tug: 100 to 101406080100120140160180200Q3 2018Q4 2018Q1 2019Q2 2019Q3 2019Q4 2019Other fitted tugs #1, Q4 2018: 100Other fitted tugs #1, Q1 2019: 98Other fitted tugs #1, Q2 2019: 104Other fitted tugs #1, Q3 2019: 102Other fitted tugs #1, Q4 2019: 69Other fitted tugs #2, Q4 2018: 100Other fitted tugs #2, Q1 2019: 88Other fitted tugs #2, Q2 2019: 96Other fitted tugs #2, Q3 2019: 88Other fitted tugs #2, Q4 2019: 87Other fitted tugs #3, Q3 2019: 100Other fitted tugs #3, Q4 2019: 99Other fitted tugs #4, Q3 2019: 100Other fitted tugs #4, Q4 2019: 88Other fitted tugs #5, Q3 2019: 100Other fitted tugs #5, Q4 2019: 97Unfitted tug, Q3 2018: 100Unfitted tug, Q4 2018: 112Unfitted tug, Q1 2019: 112Unfitted tug, Q2 2019: 112Unfitted tug, Q3 2019: 140Unfitted tug, Q4 2019: 188First fitted tug, Q3 2018: 100First fitted tug, Q4 2018: 100First fitted tug, Q1 2019: 98First fitted tug, Q2 2019: 96First fitted tug, Q3 2019: 95First fitted tug, Q4 2019: 101Unfitted tug188First fitted tug101The first fitted tug held within 5% for 18 months while the unfitted tug kept climbingUnfitted tug: 100 to 188. First fitted tug: 100 to 101406080100120140160180200Q32018Q42018Q12019Q22019Q32019Q42019Other fitted tugs #1, Q4 2018: 100Other fitted tugs #1, Q1 2019: 98Other fitted tugs #1, Q2 2019: 104Other fitted tugs #1, Q3 2019: 102Other fitted tugs #1, Q4 2019: 69Other fitted tugs #2, Q4 2018: 100Other fitted tugs #2, Q1 2019: 88Other fitted tugs #2, Q2 2019: 96Other fitted tugs #2, Q3 2019: 88Other fitted tugs #2, Q4 2019: 87Other fitted tugs #3, Q3 2019: 100Other fitted tugs #3, Q4 2019: 99Other fitted tugs #4, Q3 2019: 100Other fitted tugs #4, Q4 2019: 88Other fitted tugs #5, Q3 2019: 100Other fitted tugs #5, Q4 2019: 97Unfitted tug, Q3 2018: 100Unfitted tug, Q4 2018: 112Unfitted tug, Q1 2019: 112Unfitted tug, Q2 2019: 112Unfitted tug, Q3 2019: 140Unfitted tug, Q4 2019: 188First fitted tug, Q3 2018: 100First fitted tug, Q4 2018: 100First fitted tug, Q1 2019: 98First fitted tug, Q2 2019: 96First fitted tug, Q3 2019: 95First fitted tug, Q4 2019: 101Unfitted tug188First fittedtug101
  • Other fitted tugs
The first fitted tug held within 5% for 18 months while the unfitted tug kept climbing
SeriesQ3 2018Q4 2018Q1 2019Q2 2019Q3 2019Q4 2019
Unfitted tug100112112112140188
First fitted tug100100989695101
Other fitted tugs #1–1009810410269
Other fitted tugs #2–10088968887
Other fitted tugs #3––––10099
Other fitted tugs #4––––10088
Other fitted tugs #5––––10097
Source: GLOBAtech’s Chilean partner, results review of December 2019, from the operator’s fuel and engine-hour records. The operator’s figures are confidential: values are indexed and read from the partner’s charts, rounded. One unfitted comparison tug; not an independent trial.

Second half of 2019 against 2018: up 27% without the system, down 3% with it

Average fuel burned per main-engine hour, July to December, indexed: second half of 2018 = 100

Index (second half of 2018 = 100)

Second half of 2019 against 2018: up 27% without the system, down 3% with itSecond half 2019: 127 to 97050100150Without the system, Second half 2018: 100100Without the system, Second half 2019: 127127+27%Without the systemWith the system, Second half 2018: 100100With the system, Second half 2019: 9797−3%With the systemSecond half of 2019 against 2018: up 27% without the system, down 3% with itSecond half 2019: 127 to 97050100150Without the system, Second half 2018: 100100Without the system, Second half 2019: 127127+27%Withoutthe systemWith the system, Second half 2018: 100100With the system, Second half 2019: 9797−3%Withthe system
  • Second half 2018
  • Second half 2019
Second half of 2019 against 2018: up 27% without the system, down 3% with it
SeriesWithout the systemWith the system
Second half 2018100100
Second half 201912797
Source: GLOBAtech’s Chilean partner, results review of December 2019, from the operator’s fuel and engine-hour records. The operator’s figures are confidential: values are indexed and read from the partner’s charts, rounded. One unfitted comparison tug; not an independent trial.

What it was worth

Our partner’s estimate: had the first fitted tug deteriorated like the unfitted one, a 28% rise, it would have burned about 47,000 litres more diesel over its 850 main-engine hours in 2019. That is one tug in one year, and roughly 125 tonnes of CO₂.

Hull condition

Underwater camera inspections a year after docking found clean paint and no weed or barnacle growth on the first and second fitted tugs.

Underwater camera view of an orange-painted tug hull and bilge keel with clean paint and no barnacles
First fitted tug, about 14 months on (underwater camera, September 2019): paint visible, no weed or barnacles.
Underwater camera view of clean orange hull paint with a weld seam and no fouling
Second fitted tug, a year after docking (underwater camera, December 2019).

The launches

A port launch that had needed a dive clean every two months did not need one at its two-month check, and went more than six months without one.

How to read these figures

The figures come from the operator’s own fuel and engine-hour records, as summarised by GLOBAtech’s Chilean partner in December 2019. The operator’s data is confidential, so the charts show indexed values read from the partner’s review. There was one unfitted comparison tug, and fuel per engine hour also moves with the work a tug does, so the comparison shows a direction rather than a controlled result. In a same-port comparison in December 2019 the fitted vessel also carried some fouling, less than the unfitted one. Named fleet references are available to prospective customers on request.

What ENVSonic adds

In 2018 the evidence was photographs, fuel logs and the crew’s word. ENVSonic tests and calibrates every channel daily and records the result on the dashboard, so an operator can show that every transducer was working throughout, not just that the hull looked clean on inspection day. ENVSonic carries a three-year warranty, or five years with a Monitoring & Maintenance plan.

More from the fleet: Asia-Pacific tug fleet: from a two-tug pilot to standard fitment · All evidence · Case story (PDF) · Talk to the engineers

At a glance

The facts

Request references
~47,000 L
Diesel avoided, one tug, 2019 (est.)
+27% / −3%
Fuel per engine hour, H2 2019: unfitted / fitted
10
Tugs and launches protected by 2019
Vessel or asset Harbour tugs and port launches
Source Chilean harbour tug operator, Valparaíso Region
Region South America
Application Hulls
Outcome Fuel per engine hour held steady on fitted tugs while the unfitted tug rose 27%.

Want the in-service data for your vessel type?

We’ll share comparable installations and references from the fleet.