Compare

Antifouling and marine growth prevention methods compared

Ultrasonic, biocidal coatings, impressed current and mechanical cleaning compared on biocide release, consumables, docking, internal-system protection, monitoring and regulatory exposure.

Four ways to keep raw-water systems, hulls and running gear clean, compared on the criteria that decide specification: what goes into the water, what it consumes, whether the vessel must dock, and whether it protects the internal systems that overheat first.

Antifouling methods compared

CriterionUltrasonic (ENVSonic)Biocidal coatingsImpressed current (ICAF / MGPS)Mechanical cleaning
Biocide releaseNone. Acoustic energy only; nothing enters the water column.Continuous leaching by design; copper and co-biocides.Copper ions dosed into the seawater system.None, but in-water cleaning can release paint and organisms.
ConsumablesNone.Recoat at docking.Anodes consumed and replaced.Diver or ROV time, repeated.
DockingNo docking for most installs; retrofit in service.Docking to apply and renew.Docking or diver for anode change.In water where permitted, otherwise docking.
Through-hull penetrationsNone.Not applicable.Wet-side anodes in sea chests or strainers.Not applicable.
Protects internal seawater systemsYes: sea chests, strainers, box coolers, heat exchangers, pipework.Limited to coated surfaces; internal pipework rarely coated.Yes, downstream of the anodes.Only what can be reached and opened.
ContinuousYes, 24/7 while energised.Declines as the coating ages.Yes while dosing.No: reactive, between cleans growth returns.
MonitoringPer-channel health and daily calibration; remote on ENVS2.None.Current readings on the control unit.Inspection only.
Regulatory exposureLow: no biocide approvals, no discharge.Rising: biocide approvals under review; port restrictions on in-water cleaning of biocidal coatings.Copper discharge subject to local limits.Port-state rules on in-water cleaning; biosecurity capture requirements.

Which method when

A vessel that overheats, or a cooler that keeps blocking

Ultrasonic protection on the sea chest, strainer and box cooler is the direct answer, and it can be retrofitted without docking. See cooling systems.

A sea chest currently on impressed current

Ultrasonic removes the anode consumable and the wet-side hardware. Keep the existing system until the next anode change, then switch; the transducers bond outside the chest. See the ICAF comparison.

A hull between dockings

Coatings remain the base layer on the external hull. Ultrasonic on hull plating, running gear and seawater systems holds the hydrodynamic condition between dockings and cuts reactive cleaning. Deep-sea full-hull coverage is the part of the problem still being engineered, and we say so: what is proven by application.

A stationary asset in warm water

Barges, FSO and FPSO units, cooling towers and aquaculture intakes have no operational flow to discourage growth. Continuous ultrasonic protection is the only method that works at the same rate standing still as under way. See the MRL Resources barges.

Sources

Talk to the engineers who built it

As the OEM we design the transducers, footprint, electronics and firmware, build them in Australia, and support every system end to end, backed by a three-year complete-system warranty, or five years with a Monitoring & Maintenance plan.